New
Caramel Cake
New Venice Bakery’s caramel cake is a yellow layer cake with sweetened condensed milk and caramel in every layer, the style also known as a dulce de leche cake. It is made at our family bakery at 173 Ray Street in Garfield, NJ. Call (973) 772-2217 to order a whole caramel cake for pickup.
Description
Order Your Caramel Cake
173 Ray Street, Garfield, NJ 07026. Open every day from 7:00 AM to 8:00 PM.
What Is Our Caramel Cake?
Our caramel cake, also called a dulce de leche cake, is a yellow layer cake with sweetened condensed milk and caramel in every layer.
Dulce de leche is milk and sugar cooked slowly until it turns into a thick, golden caramel. In this cake it goes between every layer, so each slice tastes of caramel from top to bottom, not just on the frosting.
Caramel in every layer
Yellow cake, sweetened condensed milk and dulce de leche, top to bottom.
How Caramel Cakes Compare
Not every caramel cake is the same. Here is how the common styles differ, so you know what you are ordering.
Style
How it is made
Taste
Dulce de leche caramel cake (ours)
Yellow layers with sweetened condensed milk and caramel in every layer
Milky, rich caramel through the whole slice
Southern caramel cake
Yellow layers covered in a cooked caramel icing
Sweet, sugary caramel mostly in the icing
Salted caramel cake
Caramel finished with salt, often in the frosting or as a drizzle
Sweet and salty
When to Serve a Caramel Cake
Birthdays
A good pick for anyone who prefers caramel to chocolate.
Sunday dinner
A whole cake for the family table.
Holidays
A change from the usual pies at Thanksgiving and Christmas.
Serving a crowd with different tastes? Pair it with a chocolate cake such as our black forest cake.
Order a Caramel Cake for Pickup in Garfield, NJ
Before you call, have these ready:
Your pickup date and time: and call as early as you can before a holiday.
How many people you are serving: so we can talk through size.
Any message: you would like on the cake.
Pick up at 173 Ray Street, Garfield, NJ 07026, open every day from 7:00 AM to 8:00 PM. We are a short drive from Lodi, Elmwood Park and Clifton.
Need a custom cake instead?
For a decorated cake in a 5, 8, 10 or 12 inch size, use our custom cake order form and describe the flavor you want in the notes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I get a caramel cake near me in Garfield?
At New Venice Bakery, 173 Ray Street, Garfield, NJ. Call (973) 772-2217 to order one for pickup.
What is a dulce de leche cake?
A cake made with dulce de leche, a caramel made by slowly cooking sweetened milk. Ours is a yellow layer cake with sweetened condensed milk and caramel in every layer.
Is caramel cake good for a birthday?
Yes. It is a good choice for people who prefer caramel to chocolate. Ask about adding a message when you call to order.
How do I order a caramel cake?
Call (973) 772-2217 with your date and pickup time, or contact us with any questions.
More Cakes from Our Garfield Bakery
See all of our birthday cakes and Italian cakes, from tiramisu to strawberry cheesecake.
Related products
