New Venice Bakery decorates custom cakes by hand in Garfield, NJ, in 5, 8, 10 and 12 inch sizes and 21 flavors, from cannoli and tiramisu to red velvet and Oreo. Fill in the order form below with your size, flavor, filling, date and message, and we will call you to confirm every detail before your pickup.
Cake decorating is where the Imparato family story starts: John learned the trade in his family’s bakery after arriving in Brooklyn from Sicily, and hand-decorated cakes are still at the heart of the bakery. Meet the family behind New Venice.
We make custom cakes for:
Birthdays, from a first birthday to a ninetieth
Baptisms and first communions
Anniversaries and family celebrations
Holidays and Sunday dinners that need something special
Choose the size by the number of guests. The servings below are general guidance from standard bakery serving charts for a two-layer round cake; the number you get depends on how you slice.
Cake size
Generous dessert slices
Standard party slices
Best for
5 inch
about 4
about 6
A small family dinner or a cake for two to four people
8 inch
about 8
about 14 to 20
A family birthday at home
10 inch
about 12
about 25 to 28
A party with relatives and friends
12 inch
about 30
about 40
A communion, baptism or large party
Need a size that is not listed? Choose “Other” on the form and tell us your guest count. For more detail, see our cake serving chart for 5, 8, 10 and 12 inch cakes.
Every custom cake flavor on our order form, grouped by taste so you can narrow it down quickly:
Style
Flavors
Italian favorites
Cannoli, Tiramisu, Pistachio Mousse, Hazelnut Mousse, Mocha
Classic
Vanilla, Chocolate, French, Butter Cream, Whipped Cream, Custard
Fruit and fresh
Mixed Fruit, Strawberry Shortcake, Strawberry Mousse, Lemon, Coconut
Rich and creamy
Red Velvet, Cream Cheese, Carrot, Cheesecake, Oreo
Several flavors are also sold as ready-made Italian and birthday cakes, including our tiramisu cake, if you would like to try one before a big order.
Baptism and first communion parties usually mean a full house of relatives, so the cake is often the centerpiece of the table.
Size: for a family party, a 10 or 12 inch cake usually covers the guest list. Use the size table above.
Message: write the name, the date and the occasion exactly as you want them on the cake in the “Message on Cake” field.
Design: describe the colors and any symbols (a cross, a dove, rosary beads, a name in script) in “Cake Decoration Information”, and upload a sample photo if you have one.
Timing: communion season fills up in spring, so order as early as you can once you have the date.
Pair the cake with a tray: many families add a tray of cannoli, cookies or Italian pastries for the dessert table. Call us to add one to your order.
Fill in the form below with your name, email, phone and the best time to reach you.
Choose your cake: size, flavor and filling.
Pick your date in “Date Cake Requested”.
Describe the design and upload a sample image if you have one (up to 8 MB).
Write the message for the top of the cake, and add any notes.
We call you to confirm every detail, so nothing is missed in your order.
Pick up your cake at 173 Ray Street, Garfield, open every day from 7:00 AM to 8:00 PM.
Have these ready before you start the form. It makes your order faster and helps us get the cake right the first time.
Have ready
Why it matters
Guest count
Sets the size (see the table above)
Event date and pickup time
Lets us confirm the date is open
Flavor and filling
Two choices that shape the whole cake
Exact message and spelling of names
Names are the most common thing to fix at the last minute
Colors and theme
Matches the cake to the party
A photo of a cake you like
The quickest way to show the design
Allergies to mention
Tell us in the notes so we can talk it through
How far ahead should I order a custom cake?
As early as you can once you know your date. Call (973) 772-2217 if your date is coming up soon.
How many people does an 8 inch cake serve?
As general guidance, an 8 inch round cake gives about 8 generous slices or 14 to 20 thinner party slices.
Do you make baptism and first communion cakes?
Yes. We decorate celebration cakes for baptisms and first communions with your message, colors and design.
Can I send a picture of the cake I want?
Yes. Upload a sample image on the order form (up to 8 MB), and describe the design in the decoration field.
Can I order a custom cake online?
Yes. Fill in the form on this page and we will call you to confirm. You can also order by phone.
What if the flavor or size I want is not on the form?
Choose “Other” and describe it in the notes, or call us. Contact us with any other questions about your order.
Tell us your date and your guest count, and we will take it from there.